Single Screw Extruder VS Twin Screw Extruder: An In-Depth Comparison

Single screw extruder vs twin screw extruder is a common topic in the plastic processing industry. Which one is more suitable for your needs?

This comprehensive article provides a detailed comparison of these two types of extruders, highlighting their features, advantages, disadvantages, and applications to help you make an informed decision.

What is a Single Screw Extruder?

A single screw extruder operates by pushing plastic material through a heated barrel using a rotating screw. The material melts and is then extruded through a die to form the desired shape. The structure is relatively simple, consisting of a single screw and a barrel.

Working Principle

The single screw extruder consists of a long barrel with a helical screw rotating inside it. As the screw rotates, it pushes the plastic material forward, causing it to heat up due to both friction and external heaters placed along the barrel. Once the plastic is sufficiently melted, it is forced through a die to form continuous shapes like pipes, profiles, or sheets.

Advantages of Single Screw Extruder

1. Simple Structure and Easy Maintenance: The straightforward design of the single screw extruder makes it easier to maintain and operate. With fewer moving parts compared to twin screw extruders, the chances of mechanical failure are reduced, leading to lower maintenance costs.
2. Lower Cost: The manufacturing and purchasing costs of single screw extruders are generally lower than those of twin screw extruders. This makes them an economical choice for small to medium-sized operations.
3. Wide Range of Applications: Single screw extruders are suitable for processing various plastic materials such as PVC, PE, and PP. They are ideal for producing pipes, profiles, and other common plastic products, making them versatile in different manufacturing environments.

Disadvantages of Single Screw Extruder

1. Limited Mixing Efficiency: Due to having only one screw, the single screw extruder’s mixing efficiency is not as high as that of a twin screw extruder. This can be a drawback when processing materials that require thorough mixing of additives or colorants.
2. Lower Efficiency: The production efficiency of single screw extruders is usually lower, especially when handling high-viscosity or multi-component materials. This can result in longer production times and potentially higher operational costs.

What is a Twin Screw Extruder?

Figure 2 is a schematic diagram of a twin-screw extruder suitable for large-diameter PVC-U double-wall corrugated pipes.

In the figure, the labels are: 1- machine head connector, 2- twin screw, 3- heating coil, 4- machine barrel, 5- distribution box, 6- coupler, 7- frequency conversion motor, 8- machine frame, 9- double hopper, 31- cast copper heating coil, 32- cast aluminum heating coil, 41- pressure gauge.

Twin screw extruders feature two parallel or intermeshing screws. This design allows for better mixing and plasticizing of materials during extrusion, making them suitable for more complex processing tasks.

Working Principle

In a twin screw extruder, two screws rotate either in the same direction (co-rotating) or in opposite directions (counter-rotating). The intermeshing screws provide a higher shear force, which enhances the mixing and melting of the plastic material. This setup is particularly beneficial for processing materials that require uniform dispersion of fillers, reinforcements, or other additives.

Advantages of Twin Screw Extruder

1. Excellent Mixing Efficiency: The two screws in a twin screw extruder provide better shear and mixing forces, making it ideal for materials requiring high-quality mixing. This results in a more homogeneous product, which is essential for high-performance applications.
2. High Production Efficiency: Due to better mixing and conveying effects, twin screw extruders generally have higher production efficiency than single screw extruders. They can handle higher throughput and reduce overall production time.
3. Wide Range of Applications: Twin screw extruders can handle a wider variety of materials, including high-viscosity, high-fill, and heat-sensitive materials. They are widely used in engineering plastics, food, and pharmaceutical industries, where precise material handling is crucial.

Disadvantages of Twin Screw Extruder

1. Higher Cost: The manufacturing and maintenance costs of twin screw extruders are higher, requiring a larger initial investment. This can be a significant consideration for startups or businesses with limited capital.
2. Complex Operation: Due to their complex structure, operating and maintaining twin screw extruders requires higher technical skills. This may necessitate additional training for staff and could result in higher labor costs.

Application Areas Comparison

Applications of Single Screw Extruder

Single screw extruders are mainly used to produce the following products:

1. PVC Pipes: Used in construction, agriculture, and other fields. Single screw extruders are effective in producing high-quality, durable PVC pipes for various applications.
2. PE/PP Small-Diameter Hard Water Pipes: Used for water supply pipelines, gas pipelines, etc. These pipes are essential for infrastructure projects and residential plumbing.
3. Various Profiles: Including door and window profiles, decorative profiles, etc. Single screw extruders are suitable for producing a wide range of plastic profiles used in construction and home improvement.

Applications of Twin Screw Extruders

Twin screw extruders are suitable for the following areas:

1. Engineering Plastics Processing: Such as PC, PA, PBT, etc. These materials require precise mixing and control, which twin screw extruders provide.
2. High-Fill Material Processing: Such as glass fiber, carbon fiber composites. The enhanced mixing capabilities of twin screw extruders ensure uniform dispersion of fillers, resulting in stronger, more reliable products.
3. Heat-Sensitive Material Processing: Such as PVC stabilizers, medical materials, etc. Twin screw extruders can process these materials without degrading their quality, which is critical in medical and specialty applications.

Single Extruder VS Twin Screw Extruder

Next, let’s specifically understand the differences between these two types of extruders in terms of price, operability, and screws.

Items	Single Screw	Twin Screw
Screw Length-to-diameter Ratio (L/D)	comparatively small	comparatively long
Screw Cross-section Thread Shape	Rectangular	Circular
Screw Cylinder Structure	Pinch pin on screw barrel	Smooth inner surface of the screw barrel
Screw Temperature Controls	Internal screw cooling for easy temperature control	The cooling seal inside the screw is relatively poor, and the temperature is not easy to control.
Variety and Convenience of Paint Changes	Convenient	General
Difficulty of Processing Special Powder Coatings Such As Fast-curing Coatings	Comparatively Easy	General
Difficulty of Equipment Maintenance	Relatively Difficult	Easy
Sensitivity to Metallic Foreign Bodies in Boredom	Sensitive, not easy to process recycled powder materials	Less sensitive

（1）Single Screw Extruder is More Affordable

The structure of a single screw extruder is simple, thus, it’s more affordable.

The structure of a twin screw extruder is complex and more expensive. A twin screw extruder is about twice as expensive as a single screw extruder. The price can be even higher depending on the manufacturer and model.

（2）Single Screw Extruder Has a Simpler Formulation

In terms of operation, there is not much difference between the two. However, the process and formulation of a single screw extruder are simpler, while those of a twin screw extruder are more complex.

（3）Twin Screw Extruder Allows for Free Combination of Screws

The threads of a twin screw extruder can be freely combined according to the material conditions and the operator’s preferences. The single screw extruder is more rigid and does not allow for combination of screws.

（4）Twin Screw Extruder is More Efficient

The twin screw extruder has a larger output, quicker extrusion speed, and lower energy consumption per unit output than the single screw extruder. The efficiency of the twin screw extruder is mostly about twice that of the single screw extruder, depending on the manufacturer and model.

（5）Strong Plasticizing Ability of Twin-Screw

Single screw is suitable for the plasticizing extrusion of polymers, suitable for the extrusion processing of granular materials, such as molding, blow molding, injection molding, etc., with a wide range of material uses.

The twin-screw extruder has a good plasticizing and mixing ability, which is more suitable for plastic modification. And the twin-screw extruder can produce dual colors.

（6）Single Screw is Easy to Maintain

In terms of maintenance, single screw is simpler than twin screw because the structure of single screw is simpler and easier to repair.

（7）Conveying Mechanism

The conveying of the single-screw extruder mainly relies on the friction force generated between the material and the machine barrel. The counter-rotating twin-screw extruder is forward conveying, forcibly pushing the material forward, and the counter-rotating twin-screw extruder also generates shearing effect on the material at the meshing place of the two screws. (Specific to counter-rotating twin-screw extruders)

（8）Speed Field

The speed distribution in the single-screw extruder is relatively clear and easy to describe, while the situation in the counter-rotating twin-screw extruder is quite complicated and difficult to describe. This is mainly due to its screw has a meshing area, the complex flow occurring in the meshing area makes it have many advantages such as sufficient mixing, uniform heat transfer, strong melting ability, good exhaust performance, etc., but it is difficult to accurately analyze the flow state of the meshing area. (Specific to counter-rotating twin-screw extruders)

How to Choose?

When choosing between single screw and twin screw extruders, it is important to evaluate based on your specific production needs. If your production requires relatively simple operation and maintenance and deals with less complex materials, a single screw extruder may be the more economical choice. However, if your production requires efficient mixing and handling of complex materials, a twin screw extruder would be more suitable.

Consider the following factors:

• Material Characteristics: Assess the types of materials you will be processing. For high-viscosity or complex material formulations, a twin screw extruder may be necessary.
• Production Volume: Determine your required production throughput. Twin screw extruders typically offer higher throughput, making them suitable for large-scale production.
• Budget: Consider your initial investment and ongoing operational costs. Single screw extruders are generally more budget-friendly but may not meet the demands of more complex applications.
• Technical Expertise: Evaluate the technical skills of your team. Twin screw extruders require more specialized knowledge for operation and maintenance.

Conclusion

Both single screw and twin screw extruders have their advantages and disadvantages, making them suitable for different applications and production requirements. This comparison aims to help you understand which extruder is better suited for your business needs. Regardless of your choice, ensure you select a reliable supplier and high-quality product to achieve optimal production results.

We hope this article helps you better understand the differences between single screw extruders and twin screw extruders, enabling you to make a more informed decision. By carefully considering your specific needs and the capabilities of each type of extruder, you can optimize your production process and achieve better results for your business.

Tags:

Extrusion Process (1) PA Extrusion (1) Plastic Extruders (3) Reinforced Hose (2) Success Projects (1) TPE Extrusion (1) Troubleshooting (1)

References：

1. Development, Recent Advances, and Updates in Binary, Ternary Co-Amorphous Systems, and Ternary Solid Dispersions – Scientific Figure on ResearchGate. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Schematic-of-a-single-screw-and-twin-screw-extruder_fig4_372202890 [accessed 16 Jun, 2024].
2. Rauwendaal, C. (2014). Polymer Extrusion, 5th Edition. Hanser Publications. This book provides comprehensive coverage of the extrusion process, including detailed explanations of single and twin screw extruders.
3. Kluppel, M., & Wagner, M. H. (2016). Advances in Polymer Science: Polymer Processing and Structure Development. Springer. This reference details recent developments in polymer processing, including the use of extruders.
4. Throne, J. L. (1996). Technology of Thermoforming. Hanser Gardner Publications. This book includes sections on the applications of extruders in the thermoforming process.
5. Giles, H. F., Wagner, J. R., & Mount, E. M. (2005). Extrusion: The Definitive Processing Guide and Handbook. William Andrew Publishing. A thorough guide to extrusion technology, with specific chapters on single and twin screw extruders.
6. Tadmor, Z., & Gogos, C. G. (2006). Principles of Polymer Processing. John Wiley & Sons. This textbook provides a solid foundation in the principles of polymer processing, including the mechanics and operation of extruders.